Home » Public Programs » Online Exhibits » Who Counts? A History of Voting in America » How Do You Vote?

How Do You Vote?

How Do You Vote?

The entire process of political campaigns and electioneering efforts culminates in the actual casting of a vote. As the items in this case demonstrate, how we actually vote has changed a great deal over the past 200 years. Voice voting gave way to voting by paper ballot, but the form that those ballots took has changed a great deal over time, as has how those votes were cast.

The actual ballots that voters used to cast their votes sometimes took the form of “tickets” printed by political parties–voters wishing to vote a “straight ticket” would just sign their name to a pre-printed list and put that in the ballot box. The type of ballot we are familiar with today, where voters are asked to make a choice from a list of candidates, was a later arrival.

One controversial issue that arose during the Civil War was how soldiers who were deployed far away from their home towns could vote. There was extensive debate on the subject, but ultimately the decision was made to record soldiers’ votes in the field and bring those poll books back to their home districts for tabulation. As you can see, questions about mail-in ballots and voting technology are not new, and in fact have shaped what voting looks like today.

Cover of "Opinion of the Judges of the Supreme Court of Vermont, on the Constitutionality of 'An Act Providing for Soldiers Voting.'"

Vermont Supreme Court. Opinion of the Judges of the Supreme Court of Vermont on the Constitutionality of ‘An act providing for soldiers voting’”. St. Albans: Whiting and Davis, steam printers, 1864.

Pollbooks from the Pennsylvania Civil War pollbook collection, 1864. James S. Schoff Civil War Collection.

Sheet of tickets for various parties with symbols above their names. Republican Ticket column features a bald eagle, Democratic Ticket features a star, Socialist Labor Ticket features an arm holding a hammer, Prohibition Ticket Features a fountain, and Citizens Union Ticket features the Statue of Liberty. There is also a "Blank Column" with no symbol and spaces to write in specific candidates as opposed to selecting a pre-printed list of candidates from the other columns.

Blanket ballot from New York State, for Governor, Theodore Roosevelt. 1898. From the General Ephemera Collection.

Three examples of voting tickets. Far left is pink and titled "Union State Ticket," middle has many names of people running for office including Moses Kimball for Mayor, and the far right is a ticket for Branch County, Michigan, reading "For the Union" which has a list of candidates along the top with all but "Quincy" crossed out.

Tickets and ballots from The Landon Myers Collection of Early American Election Administration.
– Republican Ticket., for Mayor: Moses Kimball, Ward 3. Boston: Wright & Potter, Printers, Corner Milk and Federal Sts., 1868. From the Landon Myers Collection.
– Union State Ticket, for Governor, Rutherford B. Hayes, 1867. From the Landon Myers Collection.
– Soldier’s Field Ballot, 1864 Election, Branch County, Michigan. From the Landon Myers Collection.

Postcard depicting a lever based voting machine with the message "The Republican Lever on the Voting Machine this election is the second lever and not the first. Remember to pull the second lever when you vote Tuesday. Be sure and cast your vote early Tuesday. REPUBLICAN TOWN COMMITTEE." Arrow points to the second row of levers labeled "Rep." with the message "Pull This Lever."
Backside of a postcard dated April 8 1911.

Lever Voting Machine Instruction Card. Republican Town Committee, New Britain, CT: 1911. From The Landon Myers Collection of Early American Election Administration.